Pin it
Whenever I want to make something super easy that feels a little bit special, I reach for this set-and-forget Hawaiian chicken. Whether you pile it onto soft buns or scoop it over fluffy rice, nobody ever believes you barely had to do anything. The sweet pineapple tang with just a hint of smokiness is perfect for potlucks or hectic days.
The first batch I ever made was for my brother’s birthday party and everyone wanted seconds. Now, anytime I want to bring food people rave about, this is my pick.
Tasty Ingredients
- Boneless chicken breasts: These are your main protein. Grab fresh, thick ones for best juiciness.
- Onion, chopped: Brings in that sweet and savory background flavor. Pick onions that are nice and firm.
- Butter: Helps make the sauce richer. Go with butter and skip the margarine for top taste.
- All-purpose flour: This helps the sauce get creamy and thick, not runny. Use the scoop-and-level trick for measuring.
- Pineapple juice: The tropical must-have here. Get 100% juice—no fake stuff or sugary extras.
- Brown sugar: Makes it deep and sweet, balancing out the tang. Fresh, soft sugar works best so it blends in fast.
- Ketchup: Adds some sweet tomato punch and helps thicken the mix. I always use the no-corn-syrup type.
- Soy sauce: Kicks in that savory umami. I prefer naturally brewed—just tastes smoother.
- Fresh garlic: Brings a cozy heat. Look for firm cloves that don’t squish easily.
- Worcestershire sauce: Bumps up the smoky flavors. Splash it in, but keep it balanced.
- Salt and pepper: Pulls everything together. Fresh cracked pepper makes a big difference.
- Onion powder: Gives everything even more onion-y depth and blends the flavors nicely.
- Ground ginger: Adds a gentle spicy zing. Cracking open a new bottle gives the best pop.
Simple How-To
- Mix it up:
- In a bowl or giant measuring cup, whisk together pineapple juice, brown sugar, ketchup, soy sauce, chopped garlic, Worcestershire, salt, pepper, onion powder, and ginger. Whisk real good so no lumps stick around.
- Sauté your onions:
- Pop the butter into a pan over medium-high. When it’s bubbly, toss in your chopped onions. Let them get nice and golden at the edges and dry out a bit. That’s where all the flavor hides.
- Add the flour:
- When those onions are about ready, sprinkle in the flour. Stir it around so it turns kind of pasty. Cook for a minute or so to take away that raw taste—you want it smooth, not gritty.
- Make it saucy:
- Pour in your whisked pineapple juice mix. Keep stirring while it heats up so nothing burns. Let it bubble gently for ten or fifteen minutes, checking and stirring so it’s silky. You want it thick—like gravy that’ll coat a spoon.
- Layer the slow cooker:
- Lay chicken breasts flat inside your slow cooker. Slick them with all that sauce, making sure every piece gets hit.
- Let it slow cook:
- Set it to low and just let it go for eight hours. The chicken should fall apart without a fight and soak up those sweet savory flavors.
- Shred and finish up:
- When it’s done, pull the chicken out and shred it into little pieces with two forks. Tip it back in with the sauce and let it hang out a bit so it gets all juicy before serving.
Pin it
What gets me every time is the pineapple juice—it gives the whole dish this bright flavor punch. It always reminds me of when my youngest finished high school and we threw a beach bash. This chicken disappeared even before the rest of the food came out.
How to Store
Stick any leftovers in a covered container in the fridge. Eat it within four days for the best bite. If you’re freezing, pack it into airtight containers and keep out as much air as you can. When you thaw and reheat, splash in a little pineapple juice or chicken broth so it stays juicy.
Try Swaps
Want it a bit richer? Use boneless chicken thighs instead of breasts. Sometimes I switch out ketchup for some blended roasted red pepper—it’s awesome. If you need it gluten-free, swap in tamari for soy sauce.
Ways to Serve
Spoon this tropical chicken onto toasted buns with crunchy slaw for super tasty sandwiches. Or pile it over steamed rice or buttery noodles. It’s even awesome chilled on a salad with fresh pineapple and green onion slices on top.
Pin it
Background Info
Dishes like this one blend sweet and tangy flavors that nod to classic island-inspired eats. Pineapple and soy sauce show off Hawaiian kitchen roots, blending American barbecue and Polynesian cooking for something really inviting and unique.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why does this chicken taste sweet and a bit savory?
The pineapple juice with brown sugar gives it sweetness, and a splash of soy with garlic and a dash of Worcestershire keeps it rich.
- → What should I do if the sauce seems thin?
Let the lid sit ajar at the end so the steam can escape, or leave it alone for a bit after cooking to let it thicken up more.
- → How's this chicken best enjoyed?
Toss it on a fresh bun, spoon it onto warm rice, or drop some over a crisp salad. It's good any way you want it.
- → Can I warm up leftovers easily?
Yep, pop the chicken in a pan, microwave, air fryer, slow cooker, or oven. Add a splash of water or juice to keep it juicy.
- → Is it okay to use thighs instead?
Go for it—boneless, skinless thighs come out extra tender and tasty.