Cookies and Cream Sundae

This homemade cookies and cream ice cream sundae with caramel drizzle transforms ordinary ingredients into an extraordinary dessert experience in just minutes. The contrast between cold, creamy ice cream and crunchy cookie pieces creates that perfect texture balance while the caramel adds a buttery sweetness that ties everything together.

This sundae recipe became my secret weapon during summer gatherings when I needed something impressive without spending hours in a hot kitchen. The first time I served it at a backyard barbecue, guests were asking for the recipe before they even finished their bowls.

Ingredients

• Vanilla ice cream: premium brands with higher fat content provide the creamiest texture and richest flavor
• Chocolate sandwich cookies: the classic black and white cookies offer the perfect chocolatey crunch but any chocolate cookie works well
• Caramel sauce: store bought works perfectly but homemade adds an extra special touch if you have time
• Optional garnishes: extra whole cookies provide dramatic presentation and additional texture contrast

Step-by-Step Instructions

Crush the Cookies:

Place three cookies in a zip top bag and crush them using a rolling pin or heavy object until you have a mix of small chunks and crumbs. The varied texture creates interesting bites throughout the sundae. Reserve the remaining three cookies for garnishing your masterpiece.

Scoop the Ice Cream:

Add two generous scoops of vanilla ice cream to each serving bowl. The key here is temperature. If your ice cream is too hard, let it sit at room temperature for 3 to 5 minutes for easier scooping and a creamier texture. For picture perfect scoops, dip your scoop in warm water between each serving.

Layer the Cookies:

Sprinkle the crushed cookies liberally over the ice cream. Distribute them evenly for consistent flavor in every spoonful. Some people prefer mixing the cookies directly into slightly softened ice cream, but I find the layering method preserves the satisfying crunch better.

Drizzle Caramel Sauce:

Warm your caramel sauce slightly if it's too thick for pouring. Using a spoon, generously drizzle the sauce in a zigzag pattern across the ice cream and cookies. The contrast between the golden caramel and white ice cream creates an irresistible visual appeal.

Add Garnish:

Position halved or whole cookies standing upright in the ice cream for dramatic presentation. This not only makes the sundae look professionally crafted but also provides an extra cookie for enjoying alongside each bite of ice cream.

Serve Immediately:

Present your creation right away while the ice cream is still firm and the cookies maintain their crunch. The contrast between melting edges and firm center creates the perfect ice cream eating experience.

Pin it

My absolute favorite part of this recipe is watching the caramel slowly sink into the crevices of the ice cream, creating little pools of sweetness that you discover as you eat. It reminds me of childhood visits to my grandparents' house, where my grandmother would make similar sundaes using her homemade vanilla ice cream.

Creative Variations

This sundae welcomes endless adaptations to suit any preference. Try chocolate or coffee ice cream instead of vanilla for a more intense flavor experience. The richness of these alternatives pairs beautifully with the caramel and provides a sophisticated twist on the classic. For an extra indulgent version, add a layer of hot fudge sauce beneath the caramel.

Presentation Ideas

Elevate this simple dessert with thoughtful presentation. Serve in clear glass bowls or mason jars to showcase the beautiful layers. Chill the serving dishes in the freezer for 10 minutes before assembling to keep the ice cream from melting too quickly. For special occasions, rim the edge of the bowl with crushed cookies or sprinkles attached with a light brush of caramel sauce.

Pin it

Perfect Pairings

Balance the sweetness of this dessert with complementary beverages. A shot of espresso poured over the top creates an affogato style treat that coffee lovers will appreciate. For adults, a small glass of dessert wine or bourbon enhances the caramel notes. Children might enjoy a cold glass of milk alongside their sundae for the classic cookies and milk combination.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do I crush the cookies for this sundae?

Place cookies in a zip-top bag and crush them using a rolling pin or a heavy object to create chunky pieces.

→ Can I use store-bought caramel sauce?

Yes, store-bought caramel sauce works perfectly. You can also warm it slightly for easier drizzling.

→ What type of ice cream is best for this sundae?

Vanilla ice cream is ideal as it complements the cookies and caramel. You can try other creamy flavors as well.

→ How should I serve the sundae for the best presentation?

Use clear glass bowls to showcase the layers of cookies, ice cream, and caramel, or opt for rustic wooden bowls for a cozy vibe.

→ What additional toppings can I add?

Consider adding nuts, chocolate chips, whipped cream, or a sprinkle of sea salt to enhance the flavor and texture.

→ Can I prepare this dessert ahead of time?

It’s best to serve the sundae immediately. However, you can prepare the individual components in advance and assemble them just before serving.