Pin it
This filling Philly cheesesteak brings the real deal street food taste straight to your home without much work. When you mix razor-thin sirloin, sweet cooked onions, and gooey provolone, you'll get that true sandwich magic that hits the spot and makes you feel like you're walking down a Philadelphia street.
I got this recipe just right after visiting Philly and getting hooked on bringing that real taste back home. Now my family asks for these sandwiches every week, especially when football's on and we want something hearty but quick while we're glued to the game.
Ingredients
- Top sirloin steak or ribeye: Good quality meat really matters here, try to find some with nice fat streaks
- Provolone cheese: The classic choice that gets all melty without taking over the meat flavor
- Hoagie rolls: The real deal should have a bit of crunch outside but stay soft inside
- Yellow onion: Turns all sweet and golden when cooked down
- Bell peppers: Brings nice color and a touch of sweetness against the rich meat
- Mushrooms: Adds that savory kick that works so well with beef
- Butter and mayonnaise: Gives you that golden toasted bread and keeps it from getting soggy
- Garlic: Just a bit to boost everything else without standing out too much
- Vegetable oil: Needs to handle high heat for getting that great sear on the meat
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prep the Steak:
- Stick your steak in the freezer for half an hour to make it firm. This lets you cut those super thin slices that'll stay tender. Don't add salt and pepper until right before cooking to keep all those good beef flavors.
- Prepare the Rolls:
- Mix some soft butter with chopped garlic to make flavored butter that'll taste good in every bite. Cut the rolls but don't go all the way through so they can hold everything nicely. Toast them golden which keeps them from getting mushy when you add the juicy stuff.
- Caramelize the Onions:
- Cook your onions on medium for about 8–10 minutes without rushing. This brings out their natural sweetness that works against the meaty flavor. You'll know they're done when they look see-through with gold edges.
- Cook the Steak:
- Get your pan nice and hot for that good searing. Spread the meat out so pieces aren't touching, which helps water cook off. Let it sit still at first to get that tasty crust before you flip it. The whole thing only takes a few minutes so the meat stays tender.
- Assemble the Sandwich:
- Put the cheese right on the hot meat so it melts perfectly from the heat. The mayo on your rolls keeps them from getting wet while adding some richness. Use your spatula to flip everything into the roll while keeping all the good stuff evenly spread out.
Pin it
The real game-changer in making this recipe came when I learned about putting the meat in the freezer before slicing it. My uncle who used to work at a famous Philly cheesesteak joint told me this insider trick at our family get-together. It turned my homemade versions from just okay to truly authentic.
Perfect Cheese Options
Provolone works best in my opinion because it melts nicely and has a mild taste, but some famous Philly spots actually use Cheez Whiz for that special creamy feel. American cheese works great too if you want something that melts super smooth. No matter what cheese you pick, make sure to add it while your meat's still hot in the pan so it gets all melty and holds everything together.
Storage and Reheating
These sandwiches taste way better right after you make them, but you can wrap any extras in foil and keep them in the fridge for up to two days. When you want to eat them, just wrap the sandwich completely in foil and warm it in a 325°F oven for about 15 minutes until it's hot. I'd suggest only making as many as you'll eat right away, then keeping the parts separate if you want to make more later—they'll taste fresher that way.
Thinly Slicing Meat Techniques
Getting those paper-thin meat slices makes all the difference in how tender and authentic your cheesesteak turns out. If you're cutting it yourself, put the meat in the freezer for exactly 30 minutes till it's firm but not frozen solid, then use your sharpest knife to slice really thin pieces against the grain. For an easier way, just ask the butcher at your grocery store to slice it on their machine—you'll get perfect results with hardly any work. Some stores even sell meat already sliced just for sandwiches like this.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which steak cut works best?
Ribeye or sirloin are top choices since they’re flavorful and easy to slice thinly.
- → Is there an alternative to provolone?
Sure! Swap it with mozzarella, American, or even Cheez Whiz if you'd prefer.
- → How can I slice steak thin enough?
Pop the steak in the freezer for about 30 minutes—that’ll make it firmer and easier to cut thin pieces.
- → What extras can I throw in?
Add sautéed mushrooms, bell peppers, or a zesty sauce to punch up the flavor.
- → What bread fits perfectly?
Hoagie rolls are great, but any sturdy option that hangs onto the fillings works fine.