Pin it
There’s something awesome about tossing everything in one pot and whipping up a cheesy, beefy meal that tastes just like your favorite burger—even when you don’t have much time to spare. All the burger fixings—gooey cheese, savory beef, zippy tomato, and soft noodles—blend together so every forkful is loaded with flavor. And hey, it’s ready in only thirty minutes!
The first time I whipped this up was on a night when groceries were running thin. The family went wild for it. My husband thought it brought back memories of childhood dinners, only better than he remembered.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Chopped parsley: Tossed on at the end for that pop of freshness. Flat leaf is best if you can find it.
- Whole milk: Use it at room temperature—it makes the sauce creamy and balanced. Choose milk that’s a nice, bright white.
- Sour cream: Go for full fat and let it sit out to take off the chill. Adds creaminess and zippy tang.
- Elbow macaroni: Grab your favorite brand (just don’t overcook). This classic pasta soaks right up all the beefy, tomatoey sauce.
- Beef broth: The backbone of your sauce. If you want to keep things less salty, low sodium is a good bet.
- Tomato paste: Thickens up the sauce and brings a punch of tangy flavor. Double concentrated is even richer.
- Worcestershire sauce: Brings a tasty punch. I almost always have it hanging around for beef dishes.
- Garlic: Freshly minced, it wakes up the flavors and makes everything taste like you cooked from scratch.
- Yellow onion: Dice it up. It sweetens things and adds flavor layers. Look for ones that are small and firm.
- Ground beef: Aim for 85% lean for juicy, not greasy results. You’ll want beef that looks bright red.
- Cheddar cheese, shredded: It’s the star for that rich, melty stretch. Let it come to room temp first, and try shredding it yourself for best melt.
Easy Step-by-Step
- Add a Cheesy Topping
- Scatter the rest of the cheese all over your pasta. Put the lid back on for a few minutes on low until that cheese looks gooey and dreamy.
- Melt in the Cheddar
- Next, stir in about two and a half cups of shredded cheddar. Add a bit at a time, stirring until it all melts and gets silky smooth.
- Garnish and Dig In
- Finally, sprinkle over the chopped parsley. Dish out your pasta hot to get all that melty yumminess.
- Grab the Cheese
- Shred your block of cheddar—by hand or with a gadget. Set aside to let it lose its chill. This makes it melt in perfectly.
- Brown Up Beef and Onions
- Heat a big heavy pot on medium. Toss in beef with a little salt and pepper, breaking it up as it cooks. Once it’s lost all the pink, throw in diced onions and cook till they’re soft and starting to color—should take about five minutes. Mostly drain the fat, but keep a little for taste.
- Get the Aromatics Going
- Add the minced garlic. Stir for a minute till it smells great. Then chuck in Worcestershire and tomato paste, mixing it all together for another minute.
- Pasta Time
- Pour in the broth and macaroni, giving it all a good mix so nothing clumps. Let it start to gently simmer on medium-low.
- Simmer Away
- Put a lid on and cook for five minutes. Take it off, stir things up, then cover and simmer for five more until the pasta’s al dente and the liquid’s mostly sucked up.
- Make It Creamy
- Turn the heat way down. Mix in your sour cream and half your milk until everything looks nice and smooth. Add more milk if you want the sauce thinner.
Pin it
Cheddar’s my top pick here. Its sharp flavor cuts through the creamy sauce and turns the whole thing into a burger bowl. And now we always crush up some potato chips on top because my kid started that tradition—it’s a hit every time.
Smart Storage
Let what’s left cool before stashing it away. Pop it in sealed containers and keep it in the fridge up to four days. For reheating, splash in a bit of broth or milk and microwave in spurts, giving it a stir between bursts. Works great from the freezer, too—just bag up portions and warm from frozen when you’re low on time.
Swap Options
You can use ground chicken or turkey instead of beef. Going meatless? A plant-based ground works just fine. Switch up the cheese—mozzarella or Monterey Jack melt in beautifully along with cheddar. Any pasta shape, like penne or shells, will do the trick. Full-fat milk gives the creamiest result, but two percent is okay if that’s what you’ve got.
Ways to Serve
This goes great beside a simply dressed green salad for a fresh bite. Try spooning some into a soft roll for a messy, fun dinner. Some nights I even add sliced pickles or a squirt of mustard on top for that classic burger vibe.
Pin it
Fun Cheeseburger Casserole Origins
Inspired by the hearty flavors from old-school American diners, this dish brings together ground beef, pasta, and loads of cheese. It’s like a homemade version of boxed hamburger helper—quick, filling, and wallet-friendly. Feels nostalgic and cozy with every bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is ground turkey okay instead of beef?
For sure. Turkey gives a lighter twist but still fills you up and works just fine here.
- → How do I keep macaroni from getting mushy?
Just keep an eye while it cooks and give it a taste for a little bite left before tossing in all the creamy stuff.
- → Can I make this ahead?
Yep. Get it ready up to the cheese part, cool it down, pop in the fridge, and reheat. Finish with cheese under the broiler when you’re about to eat.
- → Could I toss in more veggies?
Why not! Add spinach, bell pepper, or mushrooms to the pan along with your onions for extra flavor and color.
- → Which cheese works best for this?
Sharp cheddar nails that burger taste, but you can swap in Monterey Jack, mozzarella, or a mix if you like a change.
- → How do I tweak the sauce thickness?
If you love it creamy, mix in a splash more milk or broth. Thicker is your jam? Simmer it longer until it looks just right.