Pin it
This go-to tuna salad is the answer when you need something tasty and fast for lunch. It’s always fresh, super easy, and fills you up every time. Creamy mayo mixes with crunchy celery and tangy pickles, so you can throw it in sandwiches or wrap it up in lettuce. My folks crave it when we just want a no-fuss meal that’ll leave us happy—and it always hits the spot.
The first time I whipped this up for a picnic, it vanished way before the potato salad did. Now, it’s my go-to whenever I want to wow folks with zero stress.
Bright Ingredients
- Fine sea salt: This brings out all the flavors. Start slow so it doesn’t end up too salty
- Baby dill pickles: Chop ‘em small for big crunch and a hit of tang. Snappy pickles work best
- Sour cream: Adds a little tang and lightens things up. Use the full-fat kind for extra creaminess
- Boiled eggs: Peel and chop eggs a couple days old—they’re easier to work with. These make your salad rich and keep you full longer
- Mayonnaise: Pulls the salad together. Full-fat brings out the best flavor
- Celery stick: Gives the salad refreshment and snap. Fresher celery is sweeter and nothing beats that crunch
- Canned tuna in water: Drain it well for lightness and to really let the tuna flavor pop. Go for solid white and dolphin safe if you can
- Yellow onion: Dice for a mellow punch. Use yellow for a low-key flavor or swap in red for more bite
- Fresh cracked black pepper: Sprinkle over for a little kick. Freshly cracked smells amazing
Simple Steps
- Chill or Dig In
- You can eat it right away, but a 20 minute chill in the fridge makes everything taste even better. This is the best way if you want to prep ahead
- Check and Add Flavor
- Season your bowl with salt and fresh pepper. Give it another stir, try a bite, and see if it needs a little more of anything. You want creamy, bright, and totally balanced flavors
- Mix Everything Up
- All the drained tuna, chopped eggs, veggies, mayo, and sour cream go straight into a big bowl. Gently break up the tuna with a fork as you stir—don’t mash it
- Prep Eggs & Veggies
- Chop your eggs after peeling, then slice up the celery, pickles, and onion as tiny as you want for nice even bites. Take your time for a neater salad
Pin it
How to Store
Pop any leftovers in a sealed container and stash in the fridge. It’ll be good for up to three days. Just give it a mix before you serve since any sauce may settle at the bottom
Swaps and Options
No sour cream? Plain Greek yogurt does the trick for that tang. Out of yellow onions? Use chopped green onions instead. For anyone avoiding dairy, pick olive oil mayo and just skip the sour cream
Creative Serving Ideas
Stack it up between slices of crunchy toasted bread or roll it up in crispy lettuce for a gluten-free bite. It’s fantastic as a topping for a big salad or scoop it up with crackers if you want a quick snack
Pin it
Classic Roots and Background
Every generation has its own spin on tuna salad—since the early 1900s, it’s kept hungry folks happy with quick, high-protein lunches. I like how making this connects me to my own childhood and now to my kids’ brown-bag lunches too
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How do I avoid soggy tuna salad?
Be sure to drain all the liquid from your tuna, then blot eggs and veggies so there’s no extra moisture. It helps keep your mix thick and creamy.
- → Fun ways to eat this salad?
Spoon it into lettuce wraps or tuck it into a sandwich, load it onto crackers or scatter over greens—it works great all sorts of ways for meals or snacks.
- → Is it okay to switch out the mayo or sour cream?
You sure can. Swap in Greek yogurt or a low-fat mayo-style spread to get the taste and texture you like.
- → How long does it stay good in the fridge?
Pop leftovers in a tight-sealed container and they’ll last up to 3 days chilled. Just give it a little mix before eating.
- → Any other good veggies to mix in?
Diced cucumber, chopped green onions, or bell peppers add even more punch and color to your salad.